Lappeenranta University of Technology

Course: 9280 Innovative Global Business Strategies

Case: Electrolux: the acquisition and integration of Zanussi

 

Student names: Harm Cox, Thoralf Czichy, Benoit Adinolfi, Tomasz Wykowski

Student email: cox@lut.fi

czichy@lut.fi

adinolfi@lut.fi

wykowski@lut.fi

 

Table of Contents

1 Assessment of Elektrolux's general global strategy *

1.1 SWOT, Core Competencies and Competitive Advantage *

1.2 SBU Portfolio Strategy *

1.3 Strategy and Objectives *

2 Evaluation of the Role of Zanussi in Electrolux's global strategy *

2.1 SWOT Analysis and Strategy *

2.2 Secret of Zanussi's Turnaround *

3 Present Situation *

3.1 Potential Problems and Decisions Made by Electrolux *

3.2 Evaluation of Whirlpool's Threats to Electrolux *

1 Assessment of Elektrolux's general global strategy

1.1 SWOT, Core Competencies and Competitive Advantage

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

Weaknesses

  • Well established team of directing managers (Electrolux Troika)
  • Experienced in using acquisitions to innovate and to enter new markets
  • Fast integration of bought businesses in Electrolux's value chain
  • Will to dispose non-profit, non-core businesses (selling off idle assets)
  • Localized sales forces
  • Subsidiaries as decentralized profit centers managed by RONA targets
  • Highly automated production facilities
  • Lean production using outsourcing for components
  • Dominant player in Nordic countries
  • Small overhead (low vertical differentiation leads to operational empowerment of local subsidiaries). Strategic aspects centralized in headquarters
  • ‘Electrolux Forecasting and Supply System’
  • Good relations with union

  • Diversifying causes sometimes financial problems (e.g. Facit, Gränges)
  • Very high focus on Western Europe and North America - not yet (?) in the rest of the world
  • Low integration of production facilities worldwide (market shifts towards low-cost, high-quality products - therefore Electrolux should move from a multi-domestic product strategy to a more global product strategy which combines world-wide economies of scale with products only slightly adapted to local consumer behavior)

Opportunities

Threats

  • Gaining advantage by being the first operating in a global scale in this industry
  • Increasing business efforts in expanding markets like Latin America and Far East
  • Product innovation can be an important aspect for global competitiveness

  • Other competitors chose to move from their domestic markets to operate in a global scale (e.g. competitors from the USA)
  • Decline in world economy may lead to financial problems (replacement demand of long-lasting consumer goods)

 

Core Competencies

Combining localization of products (incl. brand management) with globalization of product development and manufacturing (global rationalization scale of production).

Acquiring firms in a vulnerable financial position and lead them back into black figures using a straight forward approach.

Highly experienced in manufacturing and marketing of household appliances.

Competitive Advantage

Worlds largest manufacturer of high quality white goods (mainly in Europe and North America). Knowing the customers and their different needs in many countries (being close to the customer).

 

1.2 SBU Portfolio Strategy

Electrolux is organized along following five product lines (1984).

  1. Household appliances: biggest segment of Electrolux which generates 52 % of sales
  2. Forestry and Garden Products
  3. Industrial Products: heavy equipment for food services, semi-industrial laundries and commercial cleaning
  4. Commercial Services
  5. Metal and Mining (Gränges): Second largest segment with 22% of sales.

Nearly 75 per cent of sales is generated by the two biggest segments (Household appliances; Metal and Mining). These two divisions also create the major part of the profit.

 

1.3 Strategy and Objectives

Parallel to the divisional organization along product lines exists a legal structure of local subsidiaries. These subsidiaries are managed as profit centers. This may cause problems with dual responsibilities (reporting to product division and subsidiary). Electrolux is trying to establish a one product line - one company strategy. Furthermore they are trying to gain advantage of Zanussi's strong market presence in Italy, Spain, France and Germany, where Electrolux is less established as a supplier of household appliances. Additionally the product portfolios of both companies complete each other with low overlap.

 

2 Evaluation of the Role of Zanussi in Electrolux's global strategy

2.1 SWOT Analysis and Strategy

SWOT Analysis

Strengths

Weaknesses

  • Second largest private owned company in Italy
  • Offering a complete range of products
  • Well functioning distribution and sales network
  • Strong market presence of being an innovator
  • Skilled engineers

  • Unrelated diversification
  • Low quality level (esp. compared to Electrolux)
  • Conflicts in Zanussi's organization
  • Not enough skilled workforce (esp. with Electrolux's plans for automation)
  • Poor financial performance (no credibility)
  • Outdated technology
  • Underutilization of capacity
  • Prior commitments of Zanussi with Seleco and Ibelsa

Opportunities

Threats

  • See opportunities in 1.1 SWOT, Core Competencies and Competitive Advantage
  • Gaining competitive advantage from global manufacturing integration

  • See threats in 1.1 SWOT, Core Competencies and Competitive Advantage
  • Italian competitors trying to gain advantage of Zanussi’s problematic situation
  • High vendor prices to compensate the high risk of supplying to financially distressed Zanussi

 

Strategy

Electrolux was strong where Zanussi was weak and vice versa. Integrating the complementary parts of both companies in marketing as well as in product development creates good opportunity to create synergy effects. Combining the abilities of a highly vertically integrated Zanussi to produce components with Electrolux’s approach to look for external suppliers will give higher capacity utilization and economies of scale. Integration of production and developing specialization in product and brand development creates synergy that can be exploited.

2.2 Secret of Zanussi's Turnaround

The transposition of Zanussi from a financially struggling company towards a successful Electrolux business was based on a clear definition of a plan (strategy) how to achieve that. Clearly specified objectives and clearly defined milestones helped to complete the first stage of integration within a relatively short period of three to six months to maintain the momentum. Replacement of the board of Zanussi brought the new company closer to its new mission set by Electrolux. Appointing an Italian managing director, who had long experience in working with Swedish business people, as a link between both companies helped to lower barriers between both parties.

To merge both management styles Electrolux appointed several meetings of senior managers of both companies, so that they could bridge different culture and styles of management. Not to mention the effect of personal contact to create an environment without internal barriers that limit communication and information sharing.

The integration of marketing and administrative departments of both companies results in a reduction of the overall costs of the group. Shifting production, e.g. from French loss-making manufacturing, gave immediately higher capacity utilization for Zanussi’s facilities. Additionally the three areas for improvement were chosen: improving production technology, innovations and new product development and enhancing product quality.

The ability of Electrolux to deal with the strong Italian union made it easier to find a solution for the problem of low productivity and necessary work force reduction.

3 Present Situation

3.1 Potential Problems and Decisions Made by Electrolux

Electrolux is highly dependent on the success of the integration of the Italian company. Therefore the market entry of potential competitors such as Whirlpool might threaten the good position of Electrolux in the European market. Also a change in replacement demand, e.g. caused by an economic decline, might create problems for Electrolux. Therefore being able to adjust production to changing demands, not only in size, but also in structure (design, more price sensitive customers), is essential for Electrolux.

Considering the expected tough competition in a mature market offering a good localized service will be crucial to maintain market share. The highly experienced marketing employees of both companies might help to improve service quality in the consumer market.

Good long lasting relationships with suppliers (e.g. of raw material) might help to face the increasing power of suppliers, which is expected in that industry.

While empowering senior management there might be a problem how to deal with the bypassed middle management. Middle managers lost their faith in the integrity of the system formerly in use by Zanussi. This is expressed by the high number (150) of middle managers feeling less motivated and less secure. They were trying to overcome that by exposing middle managers subsequently to management development workshops.

To overcome the ‘not invented here’ syndrome and also to avoid further escalation of the frictions between engineers of both parties (e.g. no opportunity to prove themselves for Zanussi’s engineers) might be achieved by joint development teams.

On the other hand the absence of a broad base of skilled blue-collar workers needed for the introduction of a highly automated production might be a problem in the near future.

 

3.2 Evaluation of Whirlpool's Threats to Electrolux

By acquiring Philips’ appliance business Whirlpool also entered the European market and became a global player competing with Electrolux. The one who wins the race for market share has to have the better approach for satisfying the customer using one of the following aspects:

 

Whirlpool is trying to attain that by:

The company, which realizes a real global strategy will have a competitive advantage and therefore will gain market share and become a leader in this industry.